At Hearth, in New York City’s East Village, an award-winning chef rebuilt his cooking so that health and pleasure would stop arguing. Twenty-three years in, you can still taste the decision.

‍

Situated on the corner of East 12th Street and First Avenue, Hearth is a charming and intimate East Village establishment. The dining room, with its exposed brick and warm wood, feels like an invitation to stay. It is the sort of room where you gather with friends and realize three hours have slipped by, a space designed to ease you into a slower pace and nourish your spirit as much as your body.

The farm-to-table cuisine is Tuscan-American, and the menu shifts with the rhythm of the seasons. Produce is sourced from Union Square Greenmarket, exceptionally fresh and full of flavor. Ramps and morels arrive for a few weeks in spring and then they are gone; chef Marco Canora would rather let them go than serve imported substitutes in July. The kitchen operates with an uncommon commitment to ingredient integrity. Heirloom corn and wheat are milled in-house on a stone grain mill, potatoes are fried in beef fat, and the butter is grass-fed. There is no industrial seed oil anywhere in the building, making Hearth a welcome relief for anyone mindful of inflammatory foods. It is easy to view all of this as a strict set of rules, but it is better understood as a single, intuitive decision made by a chef who had run out of other options.

Marco Canora opened Hearth in 2003. He brought with him a prestigious culinary background, having worked as a key leader in Tom Colicchio's acclaimed kitchens at Gramercy Tavern and Craft, both of which earned three stars from The New York Times. He had the talent and the pedigree, but by his late thirties, the grueling culinary workweeks caught up with him. His bloodwork returned with alarming results. He was pre-diabetic with soaring cholesterol and developing gout. He had quietly cooked himself sick.

Instead of taking up a restrictive diet that would force him to sacrifice flavor, Canora set out to prove that wellness and pleasure can coexist. Following a New Year's Eve service, he closed the restaurant for just six days to refresh the space and rebuild the menu from the ground up around clean, nutrient-dense ingredients. Hearth reopened with a health-supportive focus and has remained open ever since. His cookbook, A Good Food Day, published in 2014, reads less like a diet manual and more like the record of an argument settled in the kitchen rather than the doctor's office.

‍

During his physical recovery, Canora began drinking cups of slow-simmered bone broth, finding it to be a cornerstone of his healing. In late 2014, he opened a tiny takeout window on the First Avenue side of the restaurant to share it, serving hot bone broth in paper cups like coffee. The window drew lines down the block and eventually grew into Brodo, which is now a standalone brand.

This broth is far more than a passing food trend. Simmered for hours, bone broth is packed with collagen, gelatin, and amino acids that support gut health and strengthen the immune system. At Hearth & Brodo, a warm cup of broth is treated as a grounding ritual. It can make for a soothing companion in the morning, or a way to anchor your energy in the late afternoon after a breathwork and cold plunge session.

Guests can taste this level of care across the entire menu. The Variety Burger grinds grass-fed brisket, liver, heart, and bone marrow into a single patty, dressed with caramelized onions and fontina on a toasted sesame bun. Served with crispy beef-fat-fried potatoes, it makes nutrient-rich organ meats genuinely crave-worthy. Refined sugar is absent from the kitchen, sweetness instead drawn naturally from honey, dates, maple, and dark chocolate. The wine list highlights small biodynamic and natural growers, and the non-alcoholic options are crafted with the same attention as the cocktails. Guests not drinking can enjoy botanical selections like the St. Agrestis Phony Negroni or a Casamara "Isla" amaro club soda.

Hearth makes its case quietly through the food. The restaurant operates on the belief that what is best for the planet and what is best for our bodies tend to overlap. There are no lectures here. The kitchen buys from small regional farms because the food is better and because those farms deserve to exist. It serves wild fish caught in ways that preserve the species for the next generation. It does not ask you to feel virtuous about your dinner, it simply feeds you and trusts you to notice.

‍

The Details

Hearth: 403 East 12th Street (at First Avenue), East Village, New York, NY 10009

Phone: (646) 602-1300

Website: restauranthearth.com

Instagram: @hearthrestaurant @brodo

Sister project: Brodo (brodo.com), the bone broth born at the Hearth window

Chef and founder: Marco Canora, James Beard Award, Best Chef: New York City, 2017

Reservations: restauranthearth.com/reservations, Resy-backed.

Dinner: Sun-Thurs 5 to 9:30pm, Fri-Sat 5 to 10:30pm.

Lunch: Wed-Fri 11:30am to 3pm.

Brunch: Sat-Sun 11am to 3pm.

‍

‍

Photography courtesy of Hearth.